Skip to Content

6 Best Non Toxic Bakeware Brands & Sets in 2024

6 Best Non Toxic Bakeware Brands & Sets in 2024

You love to bake. What keeps any baker up at night, however, are cookies or cupcakes sticking to the bakeware. To solve this issue, all kinds of products boast non-stick properties — but how many harmful chemicals are used when producing those kinds of products? And what soaks into the food we eat during the cooking process? Is it possible to find a happy middle-ground: bakeware that’s easy to use, easy to clean, non-stick — and non-toxic?

We’re here to say, the answer to that question is without a doubt — yes! In this ranking, we present 6 of the very best choices for non-toxic bakeware, from simple baking sheets, to ceramic and glass options. No matter what you like to bake, any one of these products will satisfy all your baking, roasting, and broiling needs, while remaining no-hassle, non-toxic, and durable. Keep reading, everything you need to know about the best non-toxic bakeware is included in this article.

Our Top Picks

Set a timer. Our non-toxic bakeware reviews are coming up next. Up first is a quick summary of each choice.

Caraway Bakeware SetBest Overall: Caraway Complete Bakeware Set.
Thoughtfully crafted with stunning design, Caraway makes the best non-toxic bakeware to buy.
casaWare 3pc multi size cookie sheet setBest Baking Sheets: CasaWare Ceramic/Carbon Non-Toxic Baking Sheet Set.
For baking sheets specifically, we like CasaWare; stick resistant, with no lead, aluminum, or other toxic chemicals.
Made In Bakeware SetBest Bakeware Set: Made In Bakeware Set.
Made from porcelain and safely reaching temps of 650 degrees, the best non-toxic ceramic bakeware comes from Made In.
Pyrex Deep Baking Dish SetBest Glass Set: Pyrex Deeper 4-Piece Set.
For both baking and food storage, the Pyrex Deeper 4 piece bakeware set is both non-toxic and made from glass.
All Clad 9000 D3 Stainless Steel Baking PanBest Stainless Steel Set: All-Clad 9000 D3 Stainless Steel Baking Pan.
Offering excellent heat transfer and easy to clean, the best non-toxic stainless steel bakeware comes from All-Clad.
Caketime Silicone Muffin Pans setBest Silicone Set: CAKETIME Silicone Non-Toxic Muffin Pan Set.
Contrary to popular belief, Lorem Ipsum is not simply random text. It has roots in a piece of classical Latin literature from 45 BC.

A Closer Look: Best Non-Toxic Bakeware

Put it in for another 5 minutes. Here’s a look at the top picks and a few things consumers did and didn’t like about the bakeware we reviewed.

Our e-label identifies eco-friendly products and brands. Learn more

1. Caraway Complete Bakeware Set

The best non-toxic bakeware on the market.

Caraway Bakeware Set

Brand: Caraway | Material: Aluminized Steel | Coating: Ceramic | Pieces:11 | Price: 💰💰💰

Free from PTFEs and made from ceramic coated aluminized steel, the 100% non-toxic Caraway bakeware set is up first in our ranking. Things catching our attention about this well-reviewed product include the mineral-based coating, ensuring nothing harmful leaches into what you’re baking. Safe at temps reaching 550°F, the set also offers stainless steel handles, and a bakeware organizer included with purchase. Otherwise, it’s all non-stick and easy to clean, with even heat distribution, according to reports.

Additional reporting on the Caraway product calls it the best bakeware set some bakers have ever used, combining beauty with sustainability, and the comfort of knowing your cookies and cupcakes will be free from harmful chemicals. There are also a few nice color options to choose from, remaining easy to clean and highly functional, and heating evenly with no sticking whatsoever, based on feedback. Isolated chipping issues have also been reported, and some find them a bit spendy for what you get, but overall, reviews of this non-toxic bakeware set call it a great quality product, and well worth the money.

  • Love the storage
  • Good size baking sheet
  • No chemicals to worry about
  • Some were “flecked” on arrival
  • Scratched up bottoms reported

2. CasaWare Ceramic Carbon Non-Toxic Baking Sheet Set

The best non-toxic baking sheets.

casaWare 3pc multi size cookie sheet set

Brand: CasaWare | Material: Carbon | Coating: Ceramic | Pieces: 3 | Price: 💰

If a non-toxic baking sheet is all you’re after, CasaWare makes the best product available. Meeting all standards laid down by the FDA, California Proposition 65, and all European Union regulations, this CaseWare product features a ceramic coating over carbon steel, remaining durable, hard to scratch, and safe to use at temperatures reaching 450°F. It’s also very easy to clean and free from cadmium, lead, PFOA, PTFE and PFOS. Also notable, this baking sheet is meant to be hand washed, immersion in water should be avoided, and neither should you use it in a microwave.

Otherwise, though, this baking sheet is a must-have for bakers, according to reports, cleaning easily with some soapy water and a soft cloth. As far as the bake, things slide right off the sheet, according to reports. Although isolated warping incidents are reported, the sheet snaps right back into shape once things cool down. This is an especially good choice if you like your cookies a little under baked. Even then, nothing sticks. The pans are durable, the coating won’t come off. They also come in a few different colors, which consumers like, and it’s even a good choice for roasted veggies, we found out.

  • Nothing sticks
  • Burnt cheese wiped right off
  • Good for chicken nuggets, pizza rolls, cookies, and tots
  • Easily scratched, some say
  • Isolated reports of flaking ceramic coating
  • 11×17? More like 10×15, according to reports

3. Made In Bakeware Set

The best non-toxic ceramic bakeware set.

Made In Bakeware Set

Brand: Made In | Material: True Porcelain | Coating: Ceramic | Pieces: 3 | Price: 💰💰💰💰

Few kinds of bakeware are as easy to clean and stain and scratch resistant as ceramic bakeware. Most importantly, ceramic bakeware, like the true porcelain bakeware set from Made In, is guaranteed to be non-toxic and that’s what we’re all about. Another advantage of this set is that it’s safe to use at much higher temperatures than other kinds of bakeware, and it’s also thermal-shock resistant and non-porous, making it all much easier to keep clean. It also has a few nice rim colors to choose from.

Otherwise, the Made In bakeware set is a great choice for browning hash browns, we learned — keeping things crisp on the outside and soft in the middle. They really are easy to clean, with a nice weight and a great size. When it comes to baking, even heat distribution is particularly important, and the Made In set shows up strong here as well. For beautiful and functional ceramic bakeware, you really can’t go wrong choosing the Made In Bakeware set. It’s also microwave safe and great for quickly reheating foods like casserole.

  • Ideal for brownies
  • Easy to grab with bulky oven mitts
  • Good choice for coffee cake and roasted potatoes
  • Pretty spendy
  • No baking sheet included
  • Dishwasher safe, but probably should hand wash
Our e-label identifies eco-friendly products and brands. Learn more

4. Pyrex Deeper Bakeware Set

The best non-toxic glass bakeware.

Pyrex Deep Baking Dish Set

Brand: Pyrex | Material: Glass | Coating: N/A | Pieces: 4 | Price: 💰

Conducting less heat, glass does take a little bit longer to heat up than metal. The trade off being, nothing compares to the even baking surface offered by glass bakeware, like the next product we reviewed. Made by Pyrex, this deep, 4-piece bakeware set is microwave safe and free from PFOA and PTFE, among other toxic chemicals. Lids are included so it’s also a good choice for food storage, or to take your casserole with you to a potluck. 

These aren’t “non-stick” per se, but glass is easy to clean and glass rarely stains, nor does it 

absorb food odors or stains. Pyrex is an established and popular brand, and consumers say this product is nice and deep, fitting nicely in a carrier to take food on the go. They also stack easily, which is convenient, and overall, it’s perfect for both baking and food storage, according to feedback. Some call the lids a bit tricky to get on, but others call them thick and sturdy.

  • Lids fit well
  • Love the depth
  • Good for lasagna and pasta
  • Just two piece
  • Lids fit well? Debatable.
  • Bit pricey for what you get

Editors Pick

A lifelong Pyrex user, it’s great to have bakeware and storage all in one. A word of caution to online shoppers, counterfeit Pyrex does exist, and it will shatter in your oven. One way to tell it’s counterfeit is that Pyrex- when it does break- shatters into small cubes, which is unique to it’s construction.

5. All-Clad 9000 D3 Stainless Steel Baking Pan

The best non-toxic stainless steel and aluminum bakeware.

All Clad 9000 D3 Stainless Steel Baking Pan

Brand: All-Clad | Material: Stainless Steel | Coating: N/A | Pieces: 1 | Price: 💰💰💰💰💰

Many turn to aluminum or stainless steel bakeware for even heat distribution and maximum durability. Our pick for the best non-toxic bakeware made from either stainless steel or aluminum comes from All-Clad. Their 9000 DE stainless steel baking pan is made from three layers of stainless steel and aluminum, withstanding heats of up to 600°F. Conveniently, the handles make it safe and convenient to take the pan in and out of the oven, whether you’re baking, broiling, or roasting, or serving. There are also a few different sizes to choose from.

Feedback on the All-Clad 9000 calls it spendy, but worth the cost. It’s well made and feels solid, with food baking evenly compared to the older pans used by a number of consumers. Some do caution care and upkeep is required to keep it all in good condition, but otherwise, it’s a nice and sturdy pan, baking evenly, and large enough for portions suiting a family of four. It’s an especially good choice for baking cakes, we learned. What’s more, the All-Clad 9000 D3 is American made, which we always like to hear.

  • No toxic coatings
  • Also good for roasts
  • Excellent heat transfer
  • One bent unexpectedly
  • Some warping reported
  • Isolated manufacturing defects

6. CAKETIME Silicone Non-Toxic Muffin Pan Set

The best non-toxic silicone bakeware.

Caketime Silicone Muffin Pans set

Brand: CAKETIME | Material: Silicone | Coating: N/A | Pieces: 6 | Spec: 💰

Made from sand-based silica, silicone is an eco-friendly alternative to plastic, while offering many similar properties to plastic such as flexibility, durability, and wide temperature toleration. Silicone is also much more durable than most plastics, and most often non-stick and BPA free. For these reasons and more, we put the CAKETIME silicone non-toxic muffin pan set in our ranking of the best non-toxic bakeware. Including both 12 and 24 cup sheets, and no matter what you bake — from cupcakes to mousse — everything pops out easy and clean.

Safe for microwaves, ovens, fridges, and freezers, this CAKETIME product is 100% food-grade silicone and versatile, whatever you’d like to bake. Notably, cupcake bottoms come out “cleanly,” and it’s easy to clean incidental drips and spills off the non-stick surface in between the cups, based on feedback. No sticking is reported, even without spraying or oiling. Some say it is necessary to put these pans in the oven on something solid, like a cookie sheet, because it all can get a little floppy, but otherwise, they pass the “pinch test” — meaning it won’t turn white when pinched, indicating no plastic fillers and only pure, non-toxic silicone.

  • Cooks more evenly than metal
  • Pour in mixture, bake, pop right out
  • Godo for egg pucks — scrambled eggs in a cupcake mold
  • Bit flimsy
  • After taste reported
  • “Pinch test” meets mixed results, some say